Introduction
The Asylum Process Can Bring Up Fear in Immigrants: Why They Need to Be Heard.
For many immigrants, the fear that their voice won’t be heard in the asylum process is real. The fear of persecution, rooted in prior trauma and current danger, affects the journeys of many seeking safety and legal status in another country.
With a record number of asylum applications around the world, it can be difficult for someone to express the fear of persecution that keeps them up at night in a way that is sufficient to gain protection.
Here’s a look at fear of persecution, its implications, and the rights of individuals seeking asylum.
Define the Fear of Persecution
Do you or someone you know fear persecution? There are many reasons why someone might fear persecution whether or not they actually face any danger. Here we explore the definition of fear of persecution in order to determine whether or not an individual could qualify for asylum or refugee status and to assist prospective applicants in understanding their situation within the context of asylum law. In order to establish a claim for asylum or for refugee status the applicant must show that the fear of persecution that they have is a well-founded fear. In other words, that their fear of persecution is real. There must be credible evidence that the applicant has faced past persecution. The past persecution could have been by the government of their home country or by a group that the government is unable to control or by a group that the government refuses to control. There must also be sufficient evidence to show that the applicant would face a reasonable basis to fear that they would be subjected to violence or to be discriminated against on the basis of their race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or on the basis of their political opinion were they to return to their home country.
For individuals trying to seek refuge through the usual channels for immigration, understanding the definition of Fear of Persecution is essential to determining how your case will be viewed through the lens of refugee law. In the case of Mambwe v. Holder, it was found that prior mistreatment by a government in an applicant’s home country created a rebuttable presumption that the applicant would suffer some kind of future harm. Thus in order to determine whether Mr. Mambwe was eligible for refugee status the court was able to accept his testimony of past persecution.
In the case of Kone v. Holder, the BIA concluded that the severe mental suffering a mother would experience were she to return to Africa and have her daughter subjected to female genital mutilation (FGM) would amount to serious harm. Thus, the mother’s fear would be sufficient to establish her eligibility for humanitarian asylum.
But for individuals whose safety is jeopardized due to the fear of persecution, it is crucial that they are aware of their rights in such cases of an emergency such as the issuance of a subpoena to testify or an encounter with ICE. But if you have been summoned as a witness or have an immigration encounter, YOU HAVE RIGHTS. The right to remain silent, the right to counsel, and the right to not be forced to sign anything that you are not sure about. If you receive a subpoena or have an immigration encounter, CALL US IMMEDIATELY. We are here to help 24/7 and can provide you with the best representation in all of your immigration cases.
Both the subjective and objective elements of a fear of persecution must be demonstrated by the asylum applicant. Evidence of the asylum applicant’s genuine fear and sufficient evidence to support the reason for said fear must be established. If the asylum applicant can demonstrate that a reasonable person in similar circumstances would also fear persecution, this is sufficient to establish a well-grounded concern for prospective applicants.
Understanding how fear of persecution is viewed by law in asylum applications is crucial for prospective applicants as laws are continually changing and evolving. Harassment and/or discrimination by itself is generally not considered to be mistreatment of another by another unless conducted in the most severe manner. Therefore, a very low level of mistreatment is all that is needed to establish a well-grounded concern that would warrant refuge in another country.
Contextualize the Fear of Persecution for Immigrants
For millions of people worldwide, life is filled with fear of persecution by local governments and other groups. In addition to fear of physical harm, many have fear of being denied legal status and forcibly removed from a country where they have lived and contributed for years or even decades. Many individuals have been persecuted by their own governments and now fear persecution by opposing regimes as well as by law enforcement within their own country and by ICE in the US.
According to Clinical Psychologist Dr. Dana Rusch recently, youth are expressing great anxiety regarding the safety of self and family members, particularly parents, while at work, grocery shopping, or even just walking in the community. Many people are forced to leave their countries of origin in search of safe haven in another country where they can apply for asylum and receive legal status to live permanently in that country.
New statistics for 2023 show that both violence and persecution are on the rise globally and as a result there are an increasing number of people who need a safe haven in another country. The first of the three newly released statistics for 944,945 asylum applications were submitted in 2023, an 88% increase from the prior year. This jump in number of people seeking asylum provides more evidence that both violence and persecution are increasing globally and a greater need for effective supportive measures and regulations to process an increasing number of people seeking asylum and safe haven in another country.
Many immigrants are anxious about being perceived as victims of persecution and are therefore prevented from accessing a variety of basic services for fear of drawing negative attention to themselves and therefore being reported to authorities and deported. Immigrants are often prevented from fully living their lives due to the tremendous amount of fear that they live with on a daily basis. This is why it is so important for there to be advocates who can compassionately and effectively advocate on behalf of immigrant individuals and families throughout the entire immigration process.
In the state of North Carolina, where there is a large and vibrant Hispanic population, there is a firm that specializes in immigration law and that serves the Hispanic community in that state: Vasquez Law Firm. Vasquez Law Firm is extremely successful in its practice of immigration law, boasting a success rate of 97% and having handled over 30,000 immigration cases.
In addition to effective representation in the many stages of the complex and difficult process of seeking and obtaining immigration status, Vasquez Law Firm meets the needs of its clients by providing community education and by supporting future professionals in the field of immigration law in order to ensure that each client receives the best possible representation.
At Vasquez Law Firm, clients are able to have their legal needs met by the firm’s experienced immigration law attorneys as well as by the firm’s affordable and accessible immigration services, which include flexible payment options. As a result of Vasquez Law Firm’s services, all families will have access to the high quality legal services that they so desperately need.
Explore the Origins of the Fear of Persecution
Does the fear of persecution due to oppression bring back horrible memories of past unfair treatment of individuals and severe human rights violations? The fear of people being persecuted for their belief or characteristics has led to some horrible historical events such as the Holocaust and ethnic cleansing found in wars like the Balkan Wars. Many political activists and/or dissidents are oppressed by their governments in ways most people cannot even imagine. These issues play a large role in today’s immigration laws and how one can establish a legitimate fear of persecution and are factors that the historical events of oppression bring to the surface for today’s asylum seekers.
Of those individuals seeking asylum today, 9 million people around the world have great fear and uncertainty of ever being able to find safe harbor. This fear can even continue after the individual has been granted refuge and re-settled in a new country. For example, currently 1.4 million plus refugee applications are pending before USCIS and that is with the current infrastructure capable of handling the current applications. Much of that fear is created by the cultural narratives of a society and the fear of oppression.
Understanding the sources of the fear of the same type of persecution that forced our ancestors to flee in order to better know the protections given today by the laws of the countries of the world to individuals who are fleeing from the very same type of persecution today, is critical to their protection. At the end of December 2025, 117.8 million individuals worldwide had been forcibly displaced as a result of war, violence, human rights abuses, or oppression by governments or other authorities. Their root causes must be addressed. All displaced individuals should be supported in their search for safe haven.
Identify Key Characteristics of the Fear of Persecution
For individuals who are fleeing from persecution and are searching for asylum in another country, the process of seeking refuge can be long, arduous, and fearful. An asylum applicant must show either with documents or personal testimony of past physical persecution or threats of persecution how he/she fears persecution by a country if he/she is returned to that country. The applicant’s fear of persecution must be for one of five reasons and therefore he/she can seek refuge based on the applicant’s race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or because the applicant is a member of a particular social group.
To establish that an applicant is eligible for asylum the applicant must establish that the applicant has a well-founded fear of persecution and therefore strong documentation and powerful personal testimony are needed to convince an immigration court that the applicant deserves refuge.
In the case of Pena-Torres v. Gonzales the Court found that the police violence that the asylum applicant suffered was a result of the applicant’s perceived sexual orientation and therefore the applicant’s credible account of past persecution with some evidence to support his account would merit consideration for asylum.
In the landmark case of INS v. Cardoza-Fonseca the Supreme Court held that an asylum applicant’s fear of persecution need only be proven by a 10% chance of harm and therefore the applicant must present evidence in the most effective way possible in order to receive the protection that they so fearfully seek as a persecuted individual.
It is well established that instances of general violence, poverty, or civil unrest in an applicant’s home country are not considered to create a well-founded fear of persecution for the purposes of an asylum application and therefore will not warrant consideration for asylum. However, if an asylum applicant has suffered past persecution or has other evidence that will affirm the applicant’s credibility as a refugee then the applicant can establish that he/she has a well-founded fear of persecution and therefore is worthy of safety and refuge.
Most asylum seekers have very little documents to substantiate their claim to asylum and even if they have filed their application on time within the one year time limit after the application has been granted the applicant may not be granted the necessary papers to rebuild his/her life such as refugee papers or even a copy of the applicant’s asylum application. The asylum seeker may not even know that these papers exist and therefore the seeker’s search for refuge could be prolonged even further and cause even more fear to the anxious seeker. Understanding these facts can mean the difference between safety and continued fear for the asylum seeker.
Conclusion
For many immigrants going through the asylum process, the fear of persecution can be overwhelming. By acknowledging this fear and using it to prepare your case, understand your rights and seek justice and safety, you can overcome your fears and come out on top.
The process of establishing a well-founded fear of persecution to seek asylum in another country can be very difficult to prove by means of sufficient evidence and powerful testimony in order to have a just claim to protection that is granted to asylum applicants. Some of the cases from past and present that have made a big impact on how cases of asylum applicants are processed by the U.S. immigration courts are presented. In addition, the situation of asylum applicants all over the world that are being persecuted by governments because of minority status that is reaching a new high in history will also be discussed.
By establishing individuals with asylees with the knowledge of their rights in these tough times it will aid greatly in seeking proper legal representation. At Vasquez Law Firm we serve the entire immigrant community from the very beginning to the very end, in any language obstacles that may interfere with full and fair rights to seek asylum as well as other immigration benefits in which they may be eligible for. We offer these clients very convenient and flexible payment plans.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the definition of fear of persecution in the context of asylum law?
Fear of persecution refers to an individual's genuine concern that they may face violence or discrimination based on their race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion if they return to their home country. To qualify for asylum or refugee status, this fear must be well-founded and supported by credible evidence of past persecution.
What must an applicant demonstrate to qualify for asylum or refugee status?
An applicant must show that their fear of persecution is real and well-founded. This includes providing credible evidence of past persecution, which could be inflicted by the government or by groups that the government cannot or refuses to control. Additionally, the applicant must demonstrate a reasonable basis for fearing future persecution.
Can past mistreatment influence an asylum claim?
Yes, past mistreatment can create a rebuttable presumption that an applicant will face future harm. For example, in the case of Mambwe v. Holder, the court accepted the applicant's testimony of past persecution as sufficient evidence for eligibility for refugee status.
How does severe mental suffering relate to fear of persecution?
In the case of Kone v. Holder, it was determined that a mother's fear of her daughter undergoing female genital mutilation (FGM) constituted serious harm, establishing her eligibility for humanitarian asylum based on her fear of persecution.
What rights do individuals have during immigration encounters or subpoenas?
Individuals have the right to remain silent, the right to counsel, and the right not to sign anything they do not understand. It is crucial to seek legal assistance immediately if summoned as a witness or during an immigration encounter.
What elements must be demonstrated by an asylum applicant regarding fear of persecution?
An asylum applicant must demonstrate both subjective and objective elements of fear. This includes evidence of their genuine fear and sufficient support for the reasons behind that fear. If a reasonable person in similar circumstances would also fear persecution, this can establish a well-grounded concern.
How is harassment or discrimination viewed in relation to fear of persecution?
Harassment or discrimination alone is generally not considered mistreatment unless it is conducted in a severe manner. A low level of mistreatment may be sufficient to establish a well-grounded concern for seeking refuge in another country.
Why is it important for prospective asylum applicants to understand fear of persecution?
Understanding how fear of persecution is viewed by law is crucial for prospective applicants, as immigration laws are continually changing. This knowledge helps applicants navigate their cases effectively within the context of asylum law.
List of Sources
- Define the Fear of Persecution
- Asylum | USCIS (https://uscis.gov/humanitarian/refugees-and-asylum/asylum)
- Well-founded fear (https://euaa.europa.eu/easo-practical-guide-qualification-international-protection/well-founded-fear-0)
-
- Elements of Asylum Law - Immigration Equality (https://immigrationequality.org/asylum/asylum-manual/asylum-law-basics-2/asylum-law-basics-elements-of-asylum-law)
- Abandoning the Subjective and Objective Components of a Well-Founded Fear of Persecution (https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/njlsp/vol16/iss2/7)
- Contextualize the Fear of Persecution for Immigrants
- The Impact of Mass Detention and Deportation Efforts on the Mental Health of Immigrant Families (https://uifightdepression.psych.uic.edu/ui-center-on-depression-and-resilience/the-impact-of-mass-detention-and-deportation-efforts-on-the-mental-health-of-immigrant-families)
- U.S. immigration policy: Mental health impacts of increased detentions and deportations (https://apa.org/monitor/2025/09/mental-health-immigration-enforcement)
- Immigrants Report Rising Fear, Negative Economic and Health Impacts, and Changing Political Views During the First Year of President Trump’s Second Term | KFF (https://kff.org/racial-equity-and-health-policy/immigrants-report-rising-fear-negative-economic-and-health-impacts-and-changing-political-views-during-the-first-year-of-president-trumps-second-term)
- Migration and Mental Health: An Overview of the Current Crisis | Denver (https://cipr.du.edu/cipr/content/migration-and-mental-health-overview-current-crisis)
- Explore the Origins of the Fear of Persecution
- Figures at a glance | UNHCR US (https://unhcr.org/us/about-unhcr/overview/figures-glance)
-
- A Brief History - Immigration Equality (https://immigrationequality.org/asylum/asylum-manual/asylum-law-basics-2/asylum-law-basics)
- The Trump Administration’s Alarming New Attacks on Refugees and Asylum Seekers (https://hias.org/news/trump-administrations-alarming-new-attacks-refugees-and-asylum-seekers)
- Persecution and Genocide: A Long History (https://politicsrights.com/persecution-and-genocide-a-long-history)
- Meet four individuals forced to flee their homes due to religious persecution (https://unrefugees.org/news/meet-four-individuals-forced-to-flee-their-homes-due-to-religious-persecution)
- Identify Key Characteristics of the Fear of Persecution
- How Can I Prove Persecution in My Asylum Case? (https://brookslawfirm.com/blog/how-can-i-prove-persecution-in-asylum-case)
- How to Prove Fear of Persecution in Your Asylum Case (https://lawofficeimmigration.com/blog/how-to-prove-fear-of-persecution.html)
- Asylum In The USA Based On Fear Of Future Persecution - Immigration Lawyer NYC | Immigration Lawyer New York | NYC Attorney (https://shautsova.com/2024/11/08/asylum-in-the-usa-based-on-fear-of-future-persecution)
- Asylum and "credible fear" issues in U.S. immigration policy (https://lbj.utexas.edu/asylum-and-credible-fear-issues-us-immigration-policy)
-
- Elements of Asylum Law - Immigration Equality (https://immigrationequality.org/asylum/asylum-manual/asylum-law-basics-2/asylum-law-basics-elements-of-asylum-law)
